Sandeep Patil Scares Me

Specifically, this little bit:

Asked whether the selectors had any specific long-term goal for the team, Patil said “No, we’re going match by match and series by series. Every match is going to be important and we want the Indian team to do well in each of those matches. Let’s not talk about the season ahead of us but this series against England that is coming up.”

It’s possible Patil meant nothing more than the usual cliche about taking each innings ball by ball. It’s more likely, however, that Patil hopes to abide by India’s long tradition of haphazard, knee-jerk and one-off selection strategy. To understand how a real thinker might approach selecting 11 cricketers, read Harsha Bhogle:

In an ideal world the new selection committee should sit down to pick two teams: one that will play the first two Tests against England, and another that will take the field in July 2014 in England, or even in November 2014 in Australia. For India to regain the No. 1 slot, both those have to be winning teams. And so if the latter teams have to be competitive, it must influence the way they pick the current team, because some investments made in players, like those made by banks in high-profile corporations, have begun to look poor.

Bhogle goes on to highlight the major problems in India’s team — the openers, the problem with the spinners and fast bowlers, what to do about Sachin Tendulkar, what to do about M.S. Dhoni’s workload — that need to be solved, or at least approached during relatively “safe” home series. The latest selection choices, however, don’t suggest much progress. Ask yourself: Is Yuvraj really the answer to 2014 Australia? Do we think either R Ashwin or P Ohja can do the job abroad? And once Zaheer leaves, are we really to depend on Umesh Yadav and Ishant Sharma?


4 thoughts on “Sandeep Patil Scares Me

  1. Rizwan Patel says:

    Hi, good topic to discuss about Indian cricket; it seems we are going to be stuck again with a committee which wont bother with long-term thinking and rathet just focus on immediate results. Hopefully we are proven wrong sonce atleast Patil saab came out gave an interview about the selection unlike Sreekanth saab who wasnt so proactive in that regard.

  2. Bogle is an enlightened sort, however I think you do have to pick your best side each game (and back your selections). In cricket there are too many injuries to plan 3 years down the line. A couple of years ago I predicted England’s bowling line up would be Tremlett, Onions and Anderson – just one of those has stayed fit long enough to secure his spot.

  3. test website says:

    Fantastic post! I?m just starting out in community management/marketing media and trying to learn how to do it effectively resources like this post are extremely beneficial. As our company is based in the US, it?s all a bit new to us. The example above is something that I worry about as well, how to show your own genuine enthusiasm and share the fact that your product is helpful in that case

  4. Impressive overcom! I would really like for you to beginner all the while an individual modify your blog, how can i join to get a website web page? The particular bank account assisted me personally the appropriate offer. For a nice and somewhat up to date with this your broadcast presented vibrant clear idea

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: