The Task of a Great Cricket Writer

I’m still shocked about the news on Peter Roebuck. I enjoyed his work, even though it was often uneven (as Sambit Bal notes in his surprisingly frank obit). I’m scared to hear what revelations the coming days will bring; I hope the cricket world isn’t about to endure a “Joe Pa” scandal.

But I just wanted to say a quick word about what a good cricket writer should do. In the past, I have compared Test cricket  to a novel, and a good cricket writer could do no better than follow the literary critic’s cue. Just as the critic asks, “Why does an author pick these particular words as opposed to others at his disposal,” the cricket critic should explain why cricketers respond to events on the field they way they do. Why do bowlers suddenly have one good spell, only to fall away in a few hours? How does a batsman encounter a threat — a swinging ball; lack of form; a doosra — and still manage to score runs? How does a captain maneuver his field to out-think a batsman?

Not many cricket writers do this well (I certainly don’t have the expertise yet). Simon Hughes (esp. in his role as The Analyst) perfected cricket criticism, but most commentators rely on vague, untested notions like “momentum” and “pressure” (as The Old Batsman notes in a wonderful post). Wasim Akram always used to say: a batsman batsman would tell him, “Line and length, line and length,” but Akram would always ask, “But why am I not bowling line and length? What’s wrong with me today?” That’s what we should be trying to answer.


2 thoughts on “The Task of a Great Cricket Writer

  1. listmon says:

    Something sure smells fishy – he calls up a friend asking him to come up, and then minutes later jumps out of the window with the cop being there ? And then the cops immediately say suicide !!

    • Ducking Beamers says:

      To me, the fishiness isn’t the suicide part. It’s entirely plausible that Roebuck committed suicide with the cops in the hotel room. The difficult part is that he was being accused of sexual assault — what’s that about?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: