What The U.S. Open Can Teach Cricket

Watching the amazing U.S. Open final between Roger Federer and Juan Del Potro, and I wanted to sum up three intramural lessons from tennis to cricket:

1. Technology hasn’t been an elixir in tennis, and it won’t be in cricket either. (I know I’ve said it before, time and again, but bear with me.)

After significant debate, tennis adopted the Hawk-eye technology that cricket only reserves for snotty comentators and replays. It’s done some great work so far, but not without some controversy. For one thing, the ball “mark” it measures sometimes seems ludicrously large when simulated, giving points where it sometimes shouldn’t. And for another, the human element remains forever. Just in today’s final, for instance, Federer clashed with the umpire about the amount of time given to his opponent for an appeal.

The New York Times explains the principle behind the champion’s frustration with technology:

The strangest case is Federer, who has long criticized the system, believing it puts the onus on players instead of on chair umpires. Federer makes challenges constantly, often for what seems like no reason, or with disdain for the entire process. Stefanki said coaches joked in the locker room that if someone like Federer missed by six inches, he should be penalized two points.

Which is also why I’ve said players should not be allowed to use technology at all in cricket, only umpires.

2. Why no women umpires in cricket? Wouldn’t that be something great? I watched a men’s match chaired by a female umpire, and I didn’t think anything about it until I remembered the way it is in cricket. Given how much animus current umpires have raised in the game, why not broaden the applicant pool?

3. The spirit of cricket isn’t a cheesy joke played by some uptight Victorians. Watch Serena Williams threaten to shove a ball down a lineswoman’s throat, and you understand the influence of the “spirit” discourse in cricket. Can you imagine any cricket player doing the same to an umpire, or even to another player, without some serious reprecussions repercussions? Mind your language, cricketers.

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “What The U.S. Open Can Teach Cricket

  1. Homer says:

    “Can you imagine any cricket player doing the same to an umpire, or even to another player, without some serious reprecussions? Mind your language, cricketers.” – Mike Gatting to Shakoor Rana 1987. Repurcussions – a poorly worded ( and spelt) letter of apology and hardship bonuses for the entire English team, courtesy the ECB

    http://www.guardian.co.uk/sport/2008/nov/23/mike-gatting-shakoor-rana

    http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/cricket/3002947/Controversial-umpire-Shakoor-Rana-dies.html

    http://www.cricinfo.com/magazine/content/story/226974.html

    Cheers,

  2. Leela says:

    Hey,

    I quite like the idea of female umpires!

  3. AlwaysIndian says:

    I too think female umpire is cool idea!!!On lighter note I guess it will add more glamor to the match 🙂

  4. i found this blog very useful for me.. i got much of knowledge about the cricket.

  5. […] even though I prefer not to have Serena Williams-like outbursts in cricket, I won’t lie that I immensely enjoyed the whole spectacle as I watched it unfold live on […]

  6. Boops says:

    Female umpires are a sensible idea and I’m surprised it hasn’t already happened. There are even female umpires in Australian football, a game not even played by women at an elite level.

    It’s important because it puts women in a position of authority (as opposed to a ‘glamorous’ position). Might even challenge the notion that God made women solely for men to gawk at.

    But then again I know how the cricket faithfuls hold misogynist traditions so close to their hearts.

  7. […] country like India. I have argued before that women should be allowed in cricket in other ways, as umpires and commentators (and not, say, as cheerleaders). Even as the authors of this article chart […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: